Can reduced processing decision support interfaces improve the decision-making of less-experienced incident commanders?

N.C Perry, M.W. Wiggins, Merilyn Childs, F. (Gerard) Fogarty

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    16 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Computer-based decision support systems have been proposed as a tool to improve the decision-making ofless-experienced personnel by reducing the information processing demands necessary for decisionmaking.This study investigated the utility of three decision support system interfaces that differed in theircapacity for reduced processing. The participants comprised experienced and less-experienced FiregroundIncident Commanders who used the decision support system interfaces to identify the most appropriateentry point to extract a victim from a simulated burning building. The results revealed that reduced processinginterfaces enabled less-experienced participants to acquire information using a process equivalent totheir more experienced counterparts. However, this process did not result in improvements in the accuracyof the decision-making process. Indeed, the accuracy of experienced participants' decisions was consistentlygreater than the less-experienced participants, irrespective of the decision support system interface. It wasconcluded that the success of reduced processing decision support systems amongst less-experienced operatorsis significantly dependent upon their understanding of the relative value of key features associated withthe decision-making process
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)497-504
    Number of pages8
    JournalDecision Support Systems
    Volume52
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Jan 2012

    Fingerprint

    Decision support systems
    Decision Making
    Decision making
    Processing
    Automatic Data Processing
    Decision support
    Incidents
    Commanders
    Personnel
    Decision-making process

    Cite this

    Perry, N.C ; Wiggins, M.W. ; Childs, Merilyn ; Fogarty, F. (Gerard). / Can reduced processing decision support interfaces improve the decision-making of less-experienced incident commanders?. In: Decision Support Systems. 2012 ; Vol. 52, No. 2. pp. 497-504.
    @article{64290dd997c84e8b96f77b7943c3e664,
    title = "Can reduced processing decision support interfaces improve the decision-making of less-experienced incident commanders?",
    abstract = "Computer-based decision support systems have been proposed as a tool to improve the decision-making ofless-experienced personnel by reducing the information processing demands necessary for decisionmaking.This study investigated the utility of three decision support system interfaces that differed in theircapacity for reduced processing. The participants comprised experienced and less-experienced FiregroundIncident Commanders who used the decision support system interfaces to identify the most appropriateentry point to extract a victim from a simulated burning building. The results revealed that reduced processinginterfaces enabled less-experienced participants to acquire information using a process equivalent totheir more experienced counterparts. However, this process did not result in improvements in the accuracyof the decision-making process. Indeed, the accuracy of experienced participants' decisions was consistentlygreater than the less-experienced participants, irrespective of the decision support system interface. It wasconcluded that the success of reduced processing decision support systems amongst less-experienced operatorsis significantly dependent upon their understanding of the relative value of key features associated withthe decision-making process",
    keywords = "Cognitive load, Decision-making, Experience, Expertise, Fire-fighting, Incident command",
    author = "N.C Perry and M.W. Wiggins and Merilyn Childs and Fogarty, {F. (Gerard)}",
    note = "Imported on 12 Apr 2017 - DigiTool details were: month (773h) = January 2012; Journal title (773t) = Decision Support Systems. ISSNs: 0167-9236;",
    year = "2012",
    month = "1",
    doi = "10.1016/j.dss.2011.10.010",
    language = "English",
    volume = "52",
    pages = "497--504",
    journal = "Decision Support Systems",
    issn = "0167-9236",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "2",

    }

    Can reduced processing decision support interfaces improve the decision-making of less-experienced incident commanders? / Perry, N.C; Wiggins, M.W.; Childs, Merilyn; Fogarty, F. (Gerard).

    In: Decision Support Systems, Vol. 52, No. 2, 01.2012, p. 497-504.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Can reduced processing decision support interfaces improve the decision-making of less-experienced incident commanders?

    AU - Perry, N.C

    AU - Wiggins, M.W.

    AU - Childs, Merilyn

    AU - Fogarty, F. (Gerard)

    N1 - Imported on 12 Apr 2017 - DigiTool details were: month (773h) = January 2012; Journal title (773t) = Decision Support Systems. ISSNs: 0167-9236;

    PY - 2012/1

    Y1 - 2012/1

    N2 - Computer-based decision support systems have been proposed as a tool to improve the decision-making ofless-experienced personnel by reducing the information processing demands necessary for decisionmaking.This study investigated the utility of three decision support system interfaces that differed in theircapacity for reduced processing. The participants comprised experienced and less-experienced FiregroundIncident Commanders who used the decision support system interfaces to identify the most appropriateentry point to extract a victim from a simulated burning building. The results revealed that reduced processinginterfaces enabled less-experienced participants to acquire information using a process equivalent totheir more experienced counterparts. However, this process did not result in improvements in the accuracyof the decision-making process. Indeed, the accuracy of experienced participants' decisions was consistentlygreater than the less-experienced participants, irrespective of the decision support system interface. It wasconcluded that the success of reduced processing decision support systems amongst less-experienced operatorsis significantly dependent upon their understanding of the relative value of key features associated withthe decision-making process

    AB - Computer-based decision support systems have been proposed as a tool to improve the decision-making ofless-experienced personnel by reducing the information processing demands necessary for decisionmaking.This study investigated the utility of three decision support system interfaces that differed in theircapacity for reduced processing. The participants comprised experienced and less-experienced FiregroundIncident Commanders who used the decision support system interfaces to identify the most appropriateentry point to extract a victim from a simulated burning building. The results revealed that reduced processinginterfaces enabled less-experienced participants to acquire information using a process equivalent totheir more experienced counterparts. However, this process did not result in improvements in the accuracyof the decision-making process. Indeed, the accuracy of experienced participants' decisions was consistentlygreater than the less-experienced participants, irrespective of the decision support system interface. It wasconcluded that the success of reduced processing decision support systems amongst less-experienced operatorsis significantly dependent upon their understanding of the relative value of key features associated withthe decision-making process

    KW - Cognitive load

    KW - Decision-making

    KW - Experience

    KW - Expertise

    KW - Fire-fighting

    KW - Incident command

    U2 - 10.1016/j.dss.2011.10.010

    DO - 10.1016/j.dss.2011.10.010

    M3 - Article

    VL - 52

    SP - 497

    EP - 504

    JO - Decision Support Systems

    JF - Decision Support Systems

    SN - 0167-9236

    IS - 2

    ER -