Concept mapping in health sciences education: Conceptualizing and testing a novel technique for the assessment of learning in anatomy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Research has shown that students feel overwhelmed by the amount of information covered in first year anatomy and physiology subjects (Eagleton, 2015). In this paper, we present an activity designed to facilitate learning of the organization of the human skeletal system and anatomical directional terms used to help describe it. Learning styles and the effect of body painting was also investigated.

Two studies are described and each were analysed separately both quantitatively (pre- and post-test scores) and qualitatively (surveys).

Body painting did not affect the number of directional terms included in the concept maps. The most common term used was “superior” and the least was “superficial”. Students applied the greatest number of directional terms to the lower limb, upper limb and vertebral column. Knowledgeable students gained no benefit from the body painting activity and from completing the concept map test a second time, whereas, the students who were naïve to the content benefited significantly from repeated testing and from body painting.

Students need scaffolding, practise and feedback to construct concept maps. Adapting the concept map tests increased student engagement and the objectivity of scoring. Learning style did not have an effect on learning outcomes of the students in this study.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-17
Number of pages17
JournalMedical Teacher
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2017

Fingerprint

health science
learning
education
student
physiology
objectivity
organization

Cite this

@article{1ab03b1494a14bd2a56c602e96a9a551,
title = "Concept mapping in health sciences education: Conceptualizing and testing a novel technique for the assessment of learning in anatomy",
abstract = "Research has shown that students feel overwhelmed by the amount of information covered in first year anatomy and physiology subjects (Eagleton, 2015). In this paper, we present an activity designed to facilitate learning of the organization of the human skeletal system and anatomical directional terms used to help describe it. Learning styles and the effect of body painting was also investigated.Two studies are described and each were analysed separately both quantitatively (pre- and post-test scores) and qualitatively (surveys).Body painting did not affect the number of directional terms included in the concept maps. The most common term used was “superior” and the least was “superficial”. Students applied the greatest number of directional terms to the lower limb, upper limb and vertebral column. Knowledgeable students gained no benefit from the body painting activity and from completing the concept map test a second time, whereas, the students who were na{\"i}ve to the content benefited significantly from repeated testing and from body painting.Students need scaffolding, practise and feedback to construct concept maps. Adapting the concept map tests increased student engagement and the objectivity of scoring. Learning style did not have an effect on learning outcomes of the students in this study.",
keywords = "concept map, anatomy, undergraduate, body painting, learning styles",
author = "N Bilton and J Rae and P Logan and G Maynard",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
doi = "10.15694/MEP.2017.000131",
language = "English",
pages = "1--17",
journal = "Medical Teacher",
issn = "0142-159X",
publisher = "Remedica Medical Education and Publishing Ltd",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Concept mapping in health sciences education: Conceptualizing and testing a novel technique for the assessment of learning in anatomy

AU - Bilton, N

AU - Rae, J

AU - Logan, P

AU - Maynard, G

PY - 2017/7

Y1 - 2017/7

N2 - Research has shown that students feel overwhelmed by the amount of information covered in first year anatomy and physiology subjects (Eagleton, 2015). In this paper, we present an activity designed to facilitate learning of the organization of the human skeletal system and anatomical directional terms used to help describe it. Learning styles and the effect of body painting was also investigated.Two studies are described and each were analysed separately both quantitatively (pre- and post-test scores) and qualitatively (surveys).Body painting did not affect the number of directional terms included in the concept maps. The most common term used was “superior” and the least was “superficial”. Students applied the greatest number of directional terms to the lower limb, upper limb and vertebral column. Knowledgeable students gained no benefit from the body painting activity and from completing the concept map test a second time, whereas, the students who were naïve to the content benefited significantly from repeated testing and from body painting.Students need scaffolding, practise and feedback to construct concept maps. Adapting the concept map tests increased student engagement and the objectivity of scoring. Learning style did not have an effect on learning outcomes of the students in this study.

AB - Research has shown that students feel overwhelmed by the amount of information covered in first year anatomy and physiology subjects (Eagleton, 2015). In this paper, we present an activity designed to facilitate learning of the organization of the human skeletal system and anatomical directional terms used to help describe it. Learning styles and the effect of body painting was also investigated.Two studies are described and each were analysed separately both quantitatively (pre- and post-test scores) and qualitatively (surveys).Body painting did not affect the number of directional terms included in the concept maps. The most common term used was “superior” and the least was “superficial”. Students applied the greatest number of directional terms to the lower limb, upper limb and vertebral column. Knowledgeable students gained no benefit from the body painting activity and from completing the concept map test a second time, whereas, the students who were naïve to the content benefited significantly from repeated testing and from body painting.Students need scaffolding, practise and feedback to construct concept maps. Adapting the concept map tests increased student engagement and the objectivity of scoring. Learning style did not have an effect on learning outcomes of the students in this study.

KW - concept map

KW - anatomy

KW - undergraduate

KW - body painting

KW - learning styles

UR - http://www.mededpublish.org/manuscripts

U2 - 10.15694/MEP.2017.000131

DO - 10.15694/MEP.2017.000131

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 17

JO - Medical Teacher

JF - Medical Teacher

SN - 0142-159X

ER -