"...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls"

Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence

Catherine Strong

Research output: Book chapter/Published conference paperConference paper

52 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

In Western societies, cultural products associated with girls or women, either as the creator or the main audience, have often been positioned at or near the bottom of the cultural hierarchy (Huyssen, 1986; Modleski, 1986:48). Examples of this include romance novels, soap operas and 'pop' music. This paper will examine the response of 'anti-fans' in on-line communities to the hugely successful Twilight series (both the books and the movie), with a view to demonstrating how the feminine nature of the series is central to the criticisms made of it and its fans. The associated naturalisation of the teenage girl as an uncritical, overly-emotional consumer of culture will be analysed as a form of symbolic violence that helps to reproduce power relations between men and women. The paper will demonstrate that the themes that arise in the discussion of Twilight coincide in many ways with debates within academia, feminism itself and wider society around the value and effects of popular culture, and ultimately contribute to the construction of a hierarchy of tastes that continues to denigrate feminine culture.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationTASA 2009
Subtitle of host publicationThe future of sociology
EditorsDan Woodman Dan Woodman
Place of PublicationAustralia
PublisherTASA
Pages1-11
Number of pages11
ISBN (Electronic)9780646525013
Publication statusPublished - 2009
EventThe Australian Sociological Association (TASA) Conference - Australian National University, Canberra, Australia
Duration: 01 Dec 200904 Dec 2009
https://tasa.org.au/tasa-conference/past-tasa-conferences/2009-tasa-conference/

Conference

ConferenceThe Australian Sociological Association (TASA) Conference
Abbreviated titleThe Future of Sociology
CountryAustralia
CityCanberra
Period01/12/0904/12/09
Internet address

Fingerprint

Symbolic Violence
Criticism
Novel
Movies
Naturalization
Feminism
Western Societies
Power Relations
Romance
Soap Opera
Emotion
Pop Music
Popular Culture
Creator

Cite this

Strong, C. (2009). "...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls": Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence. In D. W. D. Woodman (Ed.), TASA 2009: The future of sociology (pp. 1-11). Australia: TASA.
Strong, Catherine. / "...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls" : Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence. TASA 2009: The future of sociology. editor / Dan Woodman Dan Woodman. Australia : TASA, 2009. pp. 1-11
@inproceedings{dc969eb2eb034c65a83f761acd611dd9,
title = "{"}...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls{"}: Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence",
abstract = "In Western societies, cultural products associated with girls or women, either as the creator or the main audience, have often been positioned at or near the bottom of the cultural hierarchy (Huyssen, 1986; Modleski, 1986:48). Examples of this include romance novels, soap operas and 'pop' music. This paper will examine the response of 'anti-fans' in on-line communities to the hugely successful Twilight series (both the books and the movie), with a view to demonstrating how the feminine nature of the series is central to the criticisms made of it and its fans. The associated naturalisation of the teenage girl as an uncritical, overly-emotional consumer of culture will be analysed as a form of symbolic violence that helps to reproduce power relations between men and women. The paper will demonstrate that the themes that arise in the discussion of Twilight coincide in many ways with debates within academia, feminism itself and wider society around the value and effects of popular culture, and ultimately contribute to the construction of a hierarchy of tastes that continues to denigrate feminine culture.",
keywords = "Open access version available, Fandom, Gender, Online culture, Popular culture, Symbolic violence, Youth",
author = "Catherine Strong",
note = "Imported on 03 May 2017 - DigiTool details were: publisher = Australia: TASA, 2009. editor/s (773b) = Stewart Lockie, David Bissell, Alastair Greig, Maria Hynes, David Marsh, Larry Saha, Joanna Sikora and Dan Woodman; Event dates (773o) = 6-9 December 2009; Parent title (773t) = The Australian Sociological Association (TASA) Conference.",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
pages = "1--11",
editor = "Woodman, {Dan Woodman Dan}",
booktitle = "TASA 2009",
publisher = "TASA",

}

Strong, C 2009, "...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls": Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence. in DWD Woodman (ed.), TASA 2009: The future of sociology. TASA, Australia, pp. 1-11, The Australian Sociological Association (TASA) Conference, Canberra, Australia, 01/12/09.

"...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls" : Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence. / Strong, Catherine.

TASA 2009: The future of sociology. ed. / Dan Woodman Dan Woodman. Australia : TASA, 2009. p. 1-11.

Research output: Book chapter/Published conference paperConference paper

TY - GEN

T1 - "...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls"

T2 - Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence

AU - Strong, Catherine

N1 - Imported on 03 May 2017 - DigiTool details were: publisher = Australia: TASA, 2009. editor/s (773b) = Stewart Lockie, David Bissell, Alastair Greig, Maria Hynes, David Marsh, Larry Saha, Joanna Sikora and Dan Woodman; Event dates (773o) = 6-9 December 2009; Parent title (773t) = The Australian Sociological Association (TASA) Conference.

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - In Western societies, cultural products associated with girls or women, either as the creator or the main audience, have often been positioned at or near the bottom of the cultural hierarchy (Huyssen, 1986; Modleski, 1986:48). Examples of this include romance novels, soap operas and 'pop' music. This paper will examine the response of 'anti-fans' in on-line communities to the hugely successful Twilight series (both the books and the movie), with a view to demonstrating how the feminine nature of the series is central to the criticisms made of it and its fans. The associated naturalisation of the teenage girl as an uncritical, overly-emotional consumer of culture will be analysed as a form of symbolic violence that helps to reproduce power relations between men and women. The paper will demonstrate that the themes that arise in the discussion of Twilight coincide in many ways with debates within academia, feminism itself and wider society around the value and effects of popular culture, and ultimately contribute to the construction of a hierarchy of tastes that continues to denigrate feminine culture.

AB - In Western societies, cultural products associated with girls or women, either as the creator or the main audience, have often been positioned at or near the bottom of the cultural hierarchy (Huyssen, 1986; Modleski, 1986:48). Examples of this include romance novels, soap operas and 'pop' music. This paper will examine the response of 'anti-fans' in on-line communities to the hugely successful Twilight series (both the books and the movie), with a view to demonstrating how the feminine nature of the series is central to the criticisms made of it and its fans. The associated naturalisation of the teenage girl as an uncritical, overly-emotional consumer of culture will be analysed as a form of symbolic violence that helps to reproduce power relations between men and women. The paper will demonstrate that the themes that arise in the discussion of Twilight coincide in many ways with debates within academia, feminism itself and wider society around the value and effects of popular culture, and ultimately contribute to the construction of a hierarchy of tastes that continues to denigrate feminine culture.

KW - Open access version available

KW - Fandom

KW - Gender

KW - Online culture

KW - Popular culture

KW - Symbolic violence

KW - Youth

M3 - Conference paper

SP - 1

EP - 11

BT - TASA 2009

A2 - Woodman, Dan Woodman Dan

PB - TASA

CY - Australia

ER -

Strong C. "...it sucked because it was written for teenage girls": Twilight, anti-fans and symbolic violence. In Woodman DWD, editor, TASA 2009: The future of sociology. Australia: TASA. 2009. p. 1-11