Symbolic Ethnicity: A Scottish Festival Case Study

Alexandra Losurdo

Research output: ThesisMasters Thesis

74 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This study responds to the need identified by Gans (2014) for further
interrogation of fourth- and subsequent-generation practices of ‘symbolic
ethnicity’. A case study has been conducted at the 2014 Bundanoon is
Brigadoon festival to ascertain whether the concept of ‘symbolic ethnicity’
could be observed amongst festival participants. This is significant as prior
studies of symbolic ethnicity amongst fourth- and subsequent-generation
ethnic citizens have largely taken place in the United States, where the
concept of symbolic ethnicity originated. An Australian study, as has been
undertaken here, has several implications for assessing the universality of
this concept, or whether it is a particular invention of ethnic cultures in the
United States.

A Scottish festival, Bundanoon is Brigadoon, held in the town of
Bundanoon in the Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, has
been chosen as the site for this case study. The Scottish are a longestablished
migrant group in Australia, and therefore were thought to be
strong candidates for fitting the model of symbolic ethnicity. This study
responds to calls from Gans (2014) for further studies of latter-generation
ethnic participation amongst migrant groups, particularly in fourth-, fifthand
subsequent-generations, which have seen very little prior study. The
length of time since the initial waves of Scottish migration to Australia has
meant that this group has many members in the fifth generation since
migration, as well as subsequent generations. This latter-generation
ethnicity (LGE), as it has been termed, makes Scottish-Australians an ideal
group to observe in response to Gans’s (2014) suggestion for further studies.

Bauman’s (2001, 2011) theory of identity has been used as a theoretical
framework to explore the concept of symbolic ethnicity here.
Phenomenography has been employed as a methodology to explore the
nuance, experiences and perceptions of symbolic ethnicity amongst
participants at Bundanoon is Brigadoon. Using the framework of
phenomenography, semi-structured interviews and participant observation
have been used to gather data. The analysis of this resulting data was
conducted following the practices of Svensson (1997). This analysis has led
to the conclusion that symbolic ethnicity, whilst it may be at risk of decline
in coming generations, remains for now a concept that is practiced and
embraced by the Scottish Australian community. Not only was symbolic
ethnicity found to still be an active construction amongst the fifth-, sixth-,
and subsequent-generation citizens at Bundanoon is Brigadoon, the fact that
it was identified at all is indicative of a concept that can be applied and
observed in the Australian context, rather than being purely Americanbased.
Original languageEnglish
QualificationMaster of Arts
Awarding Institution
  • Charles Sturt University
Supervisors/Advisors
  • Mungai, Ndungi, Co-Supervisor
  • Crichton, Merrilyn, Co-Supervisor
Award date01 Dec 2015
Place of PublicationAustralia
Publisher
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Fingerprint

festival
ethnicity
citizen
Group
invention
candidacy
migrant
town
migration
participation
methodology
interview
community
experience

Cite this

Losurdo, A. (2016). Symbolic Ethnicity: A Scottish Festival Case Study. Australia: Charles Sturt University.
Losurdo, Alexandra. / Symbolic Ethnicity : A Scottish Festival Case Study. Australia : Charles Sturt University, 2016. 170 p.
@phdthesis{0054ad04a2f14ed282b817c69d34d784,
title = "Symbolic Ethnicity: A Scottish Festival Case Study",
abstract = "This study responds to the need identified by Gans (2014) for furtherinterrogation of fourth- and subsequent-generation practices of ‘symbolicethnicity’. A case study has been conducted at the 2014 Bundanoon isBrigadoon festival to ascertain whether the concept of ‘symbolic ethnicity’could be observed amongst festival participants. This is significant as priorstudies of symbolic ethnicity amongst fourth- and subsequent-generationethnic citizens have largely taken place in the United States, where theconcept of symbolic ethnicity originated. An Australian study, as has beenundertaken here, has several implications for assessing the universality ofthis concept, or whether it is a particular invention of ethnic cultures in theUnited States. A Scottish festival, Bundanoon is Brigadoon, held in the town ofBundanoon in the Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, hasbeen chosen as the site for this case study. The Scottish are a longestablishedmigrant group in Australia, and therefore were thought to bestrong candidates for fitting the model of symbolic ethnicity. This studyresponds to calls from Gans (2014) for further studies of latter-generationethnic participation amongst migrant groups, particularly in fourth-, fifthandsubsequent-generations, which have seen very little prior study. Thelength of time since the initial waves of Scottish migration to Australia hasmeant that this group has many members in the fifth generation sincemigration, as well as subsequent generations. This latter-generationethnicity (LGE), as it has been termed, makes Scottish-Australians an idealgroup to observe in response to Gans’s (2014) suggestion for further studies. Bauman’s (2001, 2011) theory of identity has been used as a theoreticalframework to explore the concept of symbolic ethnicity here.Phenomenography has been employed as a methodology to explore thenuance, experiences and perceptions of symbolic ethnicity amongstparticipants at Bundanoon is Brigadoon. Using the framework ofphenomenography, semi-structured interviews and participant observationhave been used to gather data. The analysis of this resulting data wasconducted following the practices of Svensson (1997). This analysis has ledto the conclusion that symbolic ethnicity, whilst it may be at risk of declinein coming generations, remains for now a concept that is practiced andembraced by the Scottish Australian community. Not only was symbolicethnicity found to still be an active construction amongst the fifth-, sixth-,and subsequent-generation citizens at Bundanoon is Brigadoon, the fact thatit was identified at all is indicative of a concept that can be applied andobserved in the Australian context, rather than being purely Americanbased.",
keywords = "libok, pdfok, oaok",
author = "Alexandra Losurdo",
year = "2016",
language = "English",
publisher = "Charles Sturt University",
address = "Australia",
school = "Charles Sturt University",

}

Losurdo, A 2016, 'Symbolic Ethnicity: A Scottish Festival Case Study', Master of Arts, Charles Sturt University, Australia.

Symbolic Ethnicity : A Scottish Festival Case Study. / Losurdo, Alexandra.

Australia : Charles Sturt University, 2016. 170 p.

Research output: ThesisMasters Thesis

TY - THES

T1 - Symbolic Ethnicity

T2 - A Scottish Festival Case Study

AU - Losurdo, Alexandra

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - This study responds to the need identified by Gans (2014) for furtherinterrogation of fourth- and subsequent-generation practices of ‘symbolicethnicity’. A case study has been conducted at the 2014 Bundanoon isBrigadoon festival to ascertain whether the concept of ‘symbolic ethnicity’could be observed amongst festival participants. This is significant as priorstudies of symbolic ethnicity amongst fourth- and subsequent-generationethnic citizens have largely taken place in the United States, where theconcept of symbolic ethnicity originated. An Australian study, as has beenundertaken here, has several implications for assessing the universality ofthis concept, or whether it is a particular invention of ethnic cultures in theUnited States. A Scottish festival, Bundanoon is Brigadoon, held in the town ofBundanoon in the Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, hasbeen chosen as the site for this case study. The Scottish are a longestablishedmigrant group in Australia, and therefore were thought to bestrong candidates for fitting the model of symbolic ethnicity. This studyresponds to calls from Gans (2014) for further studies of latter-generationethnic participation amongst migrant groups, particularly in fourth-, fifthandsubsequent-generations, which have seen very little prior study. Thelength of time since the initial waves of Scottish migration to Australia hasmeant that this group has many members in the fifth generation sincemigration, as well as subsequent generations. This latter-generationethnicity (LGE), as it has been termed, makes Scottish-Australians an idealgroup to observe in response to Gans’s (2014) suggestion for further studies. Bauman’s (2001, 2011) theory of identity has been used as a theoreticalframework to explore the concept of symbolic ethnicity here.Phenomenography has been employed as a methodology to explore thenuance, experiences and perceptions of symbolic ethnicity amongstparticipants at Bundanoon is Brigadoon. Using the framework ofphenomenography, semi-structured interviews and participant observationhave been used to gather data. The analysis of this resulting data wasconducted following the practices of Svensson (1997). This analysis has ledto the conclusion that symbolic ethnicity, whilst it may be at risk of declinein coming generations, remains for now a concept that is practiced andembraced by the Scottish Australian community. Not only was symbolicethnicity found to still be an active construction amongst the fifth-, sixth-,and subsequent-generation citizens at Bundanoon is Brigadoon, the fact thatit was identified at all is indicative of a concept that can be applied andobserved in the Australian context, rather than being purely Americanbased.

AB - This study responds to the need identified by Gans (2014) for furtherinterrogation of fourth- and subsequent-generation practices of ‘symbolicethnicity’. A case study has been conducted at the 2014 Bundanoon isBrigadoon festival to ascertain whether the concept of ‘symbolic ethnicity’could be observed amongst festival participants. This is significant as priorstudies of symbolic ethnicity amongst fourth- and subsequent-generationethnic citizens have largely taken place in the United States, where theconcept of symbolic ethnicity originated. An Australian study, as has beenundertaken here, has several implications for assessing the universality ofthis concept, or whether it is a particular invention of ethnic cultures in theUnited States. A Scottish festival, Bundanoon is Brigadoon, held in the town ofBundanoon in the Southern Highlands of New South Wales, Australia, hasbeen chosen as the site for this case study. The Scottish are a longestablishedmigrant group in Australia, and therefore were thought to bestrong candidates for fitting the model of symbolic ethnicity. This studyresponds to calls from Gans (2014) for further studies of latter-generationethnic participation amongst migrant groups, particularly in fourth-, fifthandsubsequent-generations, which have seen very little prior study. Thelength of time since the initial waves of Scottish migration to Australia hasmeant that this group has many members in the fifth generation sincemigration, as well as subsequent generations. This latter-generationethnicity (LGE), as it has been termed, makes Scottish-Australians an idealgroup to observe in response to Gans’s (2014) suggestion for further studies. Bauman’s (2001, 2011) theory of identity has been used as a theoreticalframework to explore the concept of symbolic ethnicity here.Phenomenography has been employed as a methodology to explore thenuance, experiences and perceptions of symbolic ethnicity amongstparticipants at Bundanoon is Brigadoon. Using the framework ofphenomenography, semi-structured interviews and participant observationhave been used to gather data. The analysis of this resulting data wasconducted following the practices of Svensson (1997). This analysis has ledto the conclusion that symbolic ethnicity, whilst it may be at risk of declinein coming generations, remains for now a concept that is practiced andembraced by the Scottish Australian community. Not only was symbolicethnicity found to still be an active construction amongst the fifth-, sixth-,and subsequent-generation citizens at Bundanoon is Brigadoon, the fact thatit was identified at all is indicative of a concept that can be applied andobserved in the Australian context, rather than being purely Americanbased.

KW - libok

KW - pdfok

KW - oaok

M3 - Masters Thesis

PB - Charles Sturt University

CY - Australia

ER -

Losurdo A. Symbolic Ethnicity: A Scottish Festival Case Study. Australia: Charles Sturt University, 2016. 170 p.