Abstract
That impact has, however, diminished. At its most powerful in the 1980s and early 90s, the award guaranteed five or six reprints of a short-listed title; now publishers are pleased if a short-listed title is reprinted once or twice. The reasons are complex. This paper argues, however, that the determining factor is the Children's Book Council's reluctance to acknowledge the reading choices made by children themselves. The current Awards Handbook says that the Book of the Year Award is given for:literary merit, including cohesiveness in significant literary elements; language chosen carefully for its appropriateness to the theme and style of the work with proper regard to the aesthetic qualities of language; and originality in the treatment of literary elements as they apply to the form of the work. Appeal to the implied readership under the age of eighteen is also taken into account. Judges should also consider quality of illustrations, book design, production, printing and binding. The reluctant concession 'Appeal to the implied readership under the age of eighteen is also taken into account' is highly significant. Surely in making such an award, the judges' primary concern should be the appeal a book has for children. The paper concludes that the adult judges' construction of the Book of the Year as a last bastion of literary excellence and their relegation of the criteria most important to children themselves may ironically prove counterproductive and ensure that the Children's Book Council's imprimatur means that a book is good for you, rather than good to read and may therefore diminish children's enthusiasm for reading.'The Children's Book Council of Australia Book of the Year Award and the Uses of Children's Literature' In her polemic Uses of Literature (2008) Rita Felski contends that academic literary criticism has lost sight of the reasons that readers say they respond positively to books: recognition, enchantment, knowledge and shock. This paper contrasts the criteria applied to children's books by the adult judges of literary awards, and the criteria cited by children themselves in their reviews and children's choice awards. It asks whether, in emphasising the educational uses of fiction for children, adults may be losing their way and risking the loss of potential young readers. In 1945, inspired by the inaugural year of the United Nations, a group of Australian educators, librarians and publishing industry professionals met in Sydney to set up the Children's Book Council of Australia. They believed that if they could change children's books, they would change children and if they could change children, they might change the world and ensure that the devastation of World War 2 would never be repeated.Although their strategy for change included the establishment of a children's book week, the extension of the free library network and teaching parents how to use children's books, their decision to create a Book of the Year Award had the most significant influence on children's book publishing in Australia. The Book of the Year was first awarded in 1946 and remains the country's only literary award ' for either adults' or children's books ' that has a major impact on book sales.
Original language | English |
---|---|
Title of host publication | LIT CRI' 12 |
Subtitle of host publication | New questions on literary criticism |
Editors | Efe Duyan |
Place of Publication | Istanbul, Turkey |
Publisher | Dakam |
Pages | 182-189 |
Number of pages | 8 |
ISBN (Electronic) | 9786054514045 |
Publication status | Published - 2012 |
Event | Literary Criticism conference (LIT CRI) - Istanbul, Turkey, Turkey Duration: 02 May 2012 → 05 May 2012 |
Conference
Conference | Literary Criticism conference (LIT CRI) |
---|---|
Country/Territory | Turkey |
Period | 02/05/12 → 05/05/12 |