The conceptual space explanation of the rubber hand illusion: First experimental tests

Glenn Carruthers, Xiaoqing Gao, Regine Zopf, Alicia Wilcox, Rachel A. Robbins

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Abstract

The experience of embodiment may be studied using the rubber hand illusion. Little is known about the cognitive mechanism that elicits the feeling of embodiment. In previous models of the rubber hand illusion, bodily signals are processed sequentially. Such models cannot explain some more recent findings. Carruthers (2013) proposed a multidimensional model of embodiment, in which the processing of embodiment is understood in terms of conceptual hand space. Visual features of hands are represented along several dimensions. The rubber hand illusion is then explained as the erroneous matching of the online representation of the artificial hand to the stored prototype in a space defined by those dimensions. We conducted the first experimental tests to investigate the multidimensional conceptual space account. First, participants performed a series of odd-one-out judgments for triads of hand images (including their own hand) and we then employed multidimensional scaling analyses. We found that a multidimensional model of perceived hand similarity could be fitted to our data. Second, we tested if a multisensory bodily signal manipulation (the rubber hand illusion) influences the position of the viewed artificial hand in hand space. We employed synchronous and asynchronous stroking and found that in the synchronous condition, which elicits the rubber hand illusion, compared to the asynchronous condition, which does not, the artificial hand was closer to the center of hand space; that is, to a prototype hand. We discuss these findings in the context of the Carruthers (2013) conceptual space model as well as other rubber hand illusion models.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)161-175
Number of pages15
JournalPsychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice
Volume4
Issue number2
Early online date11 May 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2017

Fingerprint

Rubber
Hand
Space Simulation

Cite this

Carruthers, Glenn ; Gao, Xiaoqing ; Zopf, Regine ; Wilcox, Alicia ; Robbins, Rachel A. / The conceptual space explanation of the rubber hand illusion : First experimental tests. In: Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice. 2017 ; Vol. 4, No. 2. pp. 161-175.
@article{8727fb4fdb944941a074e56018925212,
title = "The conceptual space explanation of the rubber hand illusion: First experimental tests",
abstract = "The experience of embodiment may be studied using the rubber hand illusion. Little is known about the cognitive mechanism that elicits the feeling of embodiment. In previous models of the rubber hand illusion, bodily signals are processed sequentially. Such models cannot explain some more recent findings. Carruthers (2013) proposed a multidimensional model of embodiment, in which the processing of embodiment is understood in terms of conceptual hand space. Visual features of hands are represented along several dimensions. The rubber hand illusion is then explained as the erroneous matching of the online representation of the artificial hand to the stored prototype in a space defined by those dimensions. We conducted the first experimental tests to investigate the multidimensional conceptual space account. First, participants performed a series of odd-one-out judgments for triads of hand images (including their own hand) and we then employed multidimensional scaling analyses. We found that a multidimensional model of perceived hand similarity could be fitted to our data. Second, we tested if a multisensory bodily signal manipulation (the rubber hand illusion) influences the position of the viewed artificial hand in hand space. We employed synchronous and asynchronous stroking and found that in the synchronous condition, which elicits the rubber hand illusion, compared to the asynchronous condition, which does not, the artificial hand was closer to the center of hand space; that is, to a prototype hand. We discuss these findings in the context of the Carruthers (2013) conceptual space model as well as other rubber hand illusion models.",
keywords = "Conceptual space, Feeling of embodiment, Quality space, Rubber hand illusion, Self-consciousness",
author = "Glenn Carruthers and Xiaoqing Gao and Regine Zopf and Alicia Wilcox and Robbins, {Rachel A.}",
note = "Includes bibliographical references.",
year = "2017",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1037/cns0000122",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "161--175",
journal = "Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice",
issn = "2326-5523",
publisher = "American Psychological Association",
number = "2",

}

The conceptual space explanation of the rubber hand illusion : First experimental tests. / Carruthers, Glenn; Gao, Xiaoqing; Zopf, Regine; Wilcox, Alicia; Robbins, Rachel A.

In: Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice, Vol. 4, No. 2, 06.2017, p. 161-175.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

TY - JOUR

T1 - The conceptual space explanation of the rubber hand illusion

T2 - First experimental tests

AU - Carruthers, Glenn

AU - Gao, Xiaoqing

AU - Zopf, Regine

AU - Wilcox, Alicia

AU - Robbins, Rachel A.

N1 - Includes bibliographical references.

PY - 2017/6

Y1 - 2017/6

N2 - The experience of embodiment may be studied using the rubber hand illusion. Little is known about the cognitive mechanism that elicits the feeling of embodiment. In previous models of the rubber hand illusion, bodily signals are processed sequentially. Such models cannot explain some more recent findings. Carruthers (2013) proposed a multidimensional model of embodiment, in which the processing of embodiment is understood in terms of conceptual hand space. Visual features of hands are represented along several dimensions. The rubber hand illusion is then explained as the erroneous matching of the online representation of the artificial hand to the stored prototype in a space defined by those dimensions. We conducted the first experimental tests to investigate the multidimensional conceptual space account. First, participants performed a series of odd-one-out judgments for triads of hand images (including their own hand) and we then employed multidimensional scaling analyses. We found that a multidimensional model of perceived hand similarity could be fitted to our data. Second, we tested if a multisensory bodily signal manipulation (the rubber hand illusion) influences the position of the viewed artificial hand in hand space. We employed synchronous and asynchronous stroking and found that in the synchronous condition, which elicits the rubber hand illusion, compared to the asynchronous condition, which does not, the artificial hand was closer to the center of hand space; that is, to a prototype hand. We discuss these findings in the context of the Carruthers (2013) conceptual space model as well as other rubber hand illusion models.

AB - The experience of embodiment may be studied using the rubber hand illusion. Little is known about the cognitive mechanism that elicits the feeling of embodiment. In previous models of the rubber hand illusion, bodily signals are processed sequentially. Such models cannot explain some more recent findings. Carruthers (2013) proposed a multidimensional model of embodiment, in which the processing of embodiment is understood in terms of conceptual hand space. Visual features of hands are represented along several dimensions. The rubber hand illusion is then explained as the erroneous matching of the online representation of the artificial hand to the stored prototype in a space defined by those dimensions. We conducted the first experimental tests to investigate the multidimensional conceptual space account. First, participants performed a series of odd-one-out judgments for triads of hand images (including their own hand) and we then employed multidimensional scaling analyses. We found that a multidimensional model of perceived hand similarity could be fitted to our data. Second, we tested if a multisensory bodily signal manipulation (the rubber hand illusion) influences the position of the viewed artificial hand in hand space. We employed synchronous and asynchronous stroking and found that in the synchronous condition, which elicits the rubber hand illusion, compared to the asynchronous condition, which does not, the artificial hand was closer to the center of hand space; that is, to a prototype hand. We discuss these findings in the context of the Carruthers (2013) conceptual space model as well as other rubber hand illusion models.

KW - Conceptual space

KW - Feeling of embodiment

KW - Quality space

KW - Rubber hand illusion

KW - Self-consciousness

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85041133090&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1037/cns0000122

DO - 10.1037/cns0000122

M3 - Review article

AN - SCOPUS:85041133090

VL - 4

SP - 161

EP - 175

JO - Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice

JF - Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice

SN - 2326-5523

IS - 2

ER -