The Metaphysical Relationship between Magic and Miracles

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Introduction: The terms 'magic' and 'miracle' are notoriously difficult to define. Considered in relation, this difficulty is magnified. In this paper I attempt to overcome this hardship by establishing a metaphysical framework, based solely upon the substance and causal relata of the events involved, within which these terms can be defined and their relationship determined. As the notion of magic has, in relation to miracles, been largely neglected within contemporary philosophy, rival definitions of magic shall be contrasted to a single fixed definition of a miracle. To ascertain which definition of magic is superior, each will be evaluated in reference to set criteria. By this method I will argue that reciprocal interactionist magic is the superior account of magic.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)103-132
Number of pages30
JournalJournal for the Academic Study of Magic
Issue number2004
Publication statusPublished - 2004

Fingerprint

Metaphysical
Magic
Miracles
Rivals
Contemporary philosophy
Causal

Cite this

@article{8d29b717119d4f1ab3f38dfcae43021c,
title = "The Metaphysical Relationship between Magic and Miracles",
abstract = "Introduction: The terms 'magic' and 'miracle' are notoriously difficult to define. Considered in relation, this difficulty is magnified. In this paper I attempt to overcome this hardship by establishing a metaphysical framework, based solely upon the substance and causal relata of the events involved, within which these terms can be defined and their relationship determined. As the notion of magic has, in relation to miracles, been largely neglected within contemporary philosophy, rival definitions of magic shall be contrasted to a single fixed definition of a miracle. To ascertain which definition of magic is superior, each will be evaluated in reference to set criteria. By this method I will argue that reciprocal interactionist magic is the superior account of magic.",
keywords = "Magic, Metaphysics, Miracles",
author = "Morgan Luck",
note = "Imported on 12 Apr 2017 - DigiTool details were: Journal title (773t) = Journal for the Academic Study of Magic. ISSNs: 1479-0750;",
year = "2004",
language = "English",
pages = "103--132",
journal = "Journal for the Academic Study of Magic",
issn = "1479-0750",
number = "2004",

}

The Metaphysical Relationship between Magic and Miracles. / Luck, Morgan.

In: Journal for the Academic Study of Magic, No. 2004, 2004, p. 103-132.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Metaphysical Relationship between Magic and Miracles

AU - Luck, Morgan

N1 - Imported on 12 Apr 2017 - DigiTool details were: Journal title (773t) = Journal for the Academic Study of Magic. ISSNs: 1479-0750;

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - Introduction: The terms 'magic' and 'miracle' are notoriously difficult to define. Considered in relation, this difficulty is magnified. In this paper I attempt to overcome this hardship by establishing a metaphysical framework, based solely upon the substance and causal relata of the events involved, within which these terms can be defined and their relationship determined. As the notion of magic has, in relation to miracles, been largely neglected within contemporary philosophy, rival definitions of magic shall be contrasted to a single fixed definition of a miracle. To ascertain which definition of magic is superior, each will be evaluated in reference to set criteria. By this method I will argue that reciprocal interactionist magic is the superior account of magic.

AB - Introduction: The terms 'magic' and 'miracle' are notoriously difficult to define. Considered in relation, this difficulty is magnified. In this paper I attempt to overcome this hardship by establishing a metaphysical framework, based solely upon the substance and causal relata of the events involved, within which these terms can be defined and their relationship determined. As the notion of magic has, in relation to miracles, been largely neglected within contemporary philosophy, rival definitions of magic shall be contrasted to a single fixed definition of a miracle. To ascertain which definition of magic is superior, each will be evaluated in reference to set criteria. By this method I will argue that reciprocal interactionist magic is the superior account of magic.

KW - Magic

KW - Metaphysics

KW - Miracles

M3 - Article

SP - 103

EP - 132

JO - Journal for the Academic Study of Magic

JF - Journal for the Academic Study of Magic

SN - 1479-0750

IS - 2004

ER -