Towards a ‘social anthropology’ of end of life moral deliberation: a study of Australian Salvation Army officers

Andrew Cameron, Bruce Stevens, Rhonda Shaw, Peter Bewert, Mavis Salt, Jennifer Ma

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

A research project by the Schools of Theology and Psychology of Australia’s Charles Sturt University surveyed a large sample of Salvation Army officers. This paper considers survey responses to two questions relating to end of life care: the use of pain medications that may shorten life, and the cessation of fluid and food intake. The results of the analyses are evaluated in terms of Michael Banner’s proposal that moral theology should more assiduously converse with ‘patient ethnographic study’, which the survey instantiates to some extent. Banner’s proposal and the results of the survey are contrasted to Peter Singer’s analytical moral philosophical dictums on end of life care. The results are also compared to a metastudy by Rodríguez-Prat and van Leeuwen of fourteen ethnographic studies of those who wish to hasten death at the end of life. We conclude that respondents exemplify a form of moral reasoning that: is embedded within Christian spirituality; counters the assumptions of Singer’s approach; contrasts the diminishment of ‘meaning’ at the end of life, as seen in Rodríguez-Prat and van Leeuwen; and deserves further respectful ethnographic study.
Original languageEnglish
JournalStudies in Christian Ethics
DOIs
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2019

Fingerprint

End of Life
Social Anthropology
Salvation Army
Ethnographic Study
Moral Deliberation
End of Life Care
Psychology
Food
Singers
Peter Singer
Moral Reasoning
Dictum
Christian Spirituality
Medication
Theology
Moral Theology
Wishes
Pain
Intake
Research Projects

Cite this

@article{27beeeaa92624e259533f6576ed21883,
title = "Towards a ‘social anthropology’ of end of life moral deliberation: a study of Australian Salvation Army officers",
abstract = "A research project by the Schools of Theology and Psychology of Australia’s Charles Sturt University surveyed a large sample of Salvation Army officers. This paper considers survey responses to two questions relating to end of life care: the use of pain medications that may shorten life, and the cessation of fluid and food intake. The results of the analyses are evaluated in terms of Michael Banner’s proposal that moral theology should more assiduously converse with ‘patient ethnographic study’, which the survey instantiates to some extent. Banner’s proposal and the results of the survey are contrasted to Peter Singer’s analytical moral philosophical dictums on end of life care. The results are also compared to a metastudy by Rodr{\'i}guez-Prat and van Leeuwen of fourteen ethnographic studies of those who wish to hasten death at the end of life. We conclude that respondents exemplify a form of moral reasoning that: is embedded within Christian spirituality; counters the assumptions of Singer’s approach; contrasts the diminishment of ‘meaning’ at the end of life, as seen in Rodr{\'i}guez-Prat and van Leeuwen; and deserves further respectful ethnographic study.",
author = "Andrew Cameron and Bruce Stevens and Rhonda Shaw and Peter Bewert and Mavis Salt and Jennifer Ma",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1177/0953946819847996",
language = "English",
journal = "Studies in Christian Ethics",
issn = "0953-9468",
publisher = "Academic Press",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Towards a ‘social anthropology’ of end of life moral deliberation: a study of Australian Salvation Army officers

AU - Cameron, Andrew

AU - Stevens, Bruce

AU - Shaw, Rhonda

AU - Bewert, Peter

AU - Salt, Mavis

AU - Ma, Jennifer

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - A research project by the Schools of Theology and Psychology of Australia’s Charles Sturt University surveyed a large sample of Salvation Army officers. This paper considers survey responses to two questions relating to end of life care: the use of pain medications that may shorten life, and the cessation of fluid and food intake. The results of the analyses are evaluated in terms of Michael Banner’s proposal that moral theology should more assiduously converse with ‘patient ethnographic study’, which the survey instantiates to some extent. Banner’s proposal and the results of the survey are contrasted to Peter Singer’s analytical moral philosophical dictums on end of life care. The results are also compared to a metastudy by Rodríguez-Prat and van Leeuwen of fourteen ethnographic studies of those who wish to hasten death at the end of life. We conclude that respondents exemplify a form of moral reasoning that: is embedded within Christian spirituality; counters the assumptions of Singer’s approach; contrasts the diminishment of ‘meaning’ at the end of life, as seen in Rodríguez-Prat and van Leeuwen; and deserves further respectful ethnographic study.

AB - A research project by the Schools of Theology and Psychology of Australia’s Charles Sturt University surveyed a large sample of Salvation Army officers. This paper considers survey responses to two questions relating to end of life care: the use of pain medications that may shorten life, and the cessation of fluid and food intake. The results of the analyses are evaluated in terms of Michael Banner’s proposal that moral theology should more assiduously converse with ‘patient ethnographic study’, which the survey instantiates to some extent. Banner’s proposal and the results of the survey are contrasted to Peter Singer’s analytical moral philosophical dictums on end of life care. The results are also compared to a metastudy by Rodríguez-Prat and van Leeuwen of fourteen ethnographic studies of those who wish to hasten death at the end of life. We conclude that respondents exemplify a form of moral reasoning that: is embedded within Christian spirituality; counters the assumptions of Singer’s approach; contrasts the diminishment of ‘meaning’ at the end of life, as seen in Rodríguez-Prat and van Leeuwen; and deserves further respectful ethnographic study.

U2 - 10.1177/0953946819847996

DO - 10.1177/0953946819847996

M3 - Article

JO - Studies in Christian Ethics

JF - Studies in Christian Ethics

SN - 0953-9468

ER -